Do Protein Bars and Shakes Make You Gain Weight?

Do Protein Bars and Shakes Make You Gain Weight?

Get the best Diet Tips at Diet Nutrition Advisor

The macronutrients– carbohydrates, fats and protein– are important for optimal health. While carbs and fats provide the body with energy, protein supports muscular development and development, as well as tissue repair work. John M. Berardi, Ph.D., describes that protein is a specifically essential macronutrient for athletes as it advertises muscle health while improving athletic performance. Berardi suggests that strength and endurance athletes consume in between 1.4 and 2.0 grams of protein per kilogram of body mass. Protein could be included into the diet by means of protein bars and shakes, nevertheless, the carb content and caloric value of bench or shake could cause weight gain depending on your level of activity. Speak with your health care adviser prior to ingesting a protein bar or shake.


Although carbs are a vital macronutrient for health, excessive consumption of carbohydrates may get saved as fat. In the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans, the USDA suggests that the typical adult consume in between 45 percent and 65 percent carbs. Competitive athletes, nonetheless, might need a substantially higher carbohydrate intake. Additionally, athletes should integrate carbs with a source of protein for ideal post-workout recovery, according to a short article released in the December 2010 version of ‘International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism.’ Considering that the common protein bar includes 30 g of carbs versus 1 g of carbohydrates discovered in protein shakes, athletes may choose the protein bars over the protein shakes for athletic efficiency. Non-athletes, on the other hand, may want to go with the protein shakes instead of the protein bars for weight control.


In general, protein shakes have a lower fat and fiber material in comparison to protein bars. Fat and fiber are two nutrients that advertise satiation, which supports appetite control and might assist to prevent weight gain over the long term. In addition, protein bars often consist of a mix of proteins, such as casein and soy protein, which also increase levels of satiation as they’ve a slower rate of absorption than whey protein, the major constituent of protein shakes. People who wish to regulate hunger between dishes might find greater fulfillment in protein bars. Given that whey protein is easily absorbed by the body, athletes could like to ingest protein shakes post-workout for a quick recovery.

Caloric Value

The typical protein shake supplies about 110 calories, while a protein bar could supply as much as 350 calories. Although the calorie material of both protein shakes and protein bars are unlikely to influence competitive athletes, non-athletes ought to be weary of the high-caloric value of protein bars. Consuming several bars throughout the day with very little exercise might cause weight gain.


An person’s total diet and fitness regimen is most likely to add to weight fluctuations than protein bars or shakes alone. Protein bars or shakes mustn’t be depended upon as a therapy technique for abnormal body mass, rather, they should go along with a nutritious eating strategy and exercise routine. Determining whether to consume a protein shake or a protein bar relies on your physical fitness objectives, along with your existing level of exercising. Try out incorporating the protein shake or bar with extra nutritional food items, such as a banana or soy milk, could help to sustain your exercise program without resulting in weight gain.